Crogin Gaming Network

World

Fishing

There are fifteen kinds of fish and a legendary version of each. Fishing is a quiet way to raise Health, earn honor and make cash, and several challenges and the 100% checklist depend on it.

Story ModeSpoiler-safe

Checked Sep 30, 2026 · Sources: OfficialCommunityCGN

A wooden rowboat, a wicker creel, a satchel and a fishing rod on the shore of a still mountain lake, with mist, pine forest and snow-capped peaks beyond.
CGN fan art

Getting started

  • The rod. You get a fishing rod during an early story mission. Until then, you can take one from an NPC, but only a few basic baits work.
  • Where. Rivers, lakes, ponds and swamps. Some species live almost anywhere and others live in one habitat.
  • Eagle Eye. With the rod out, Eagle Eye makes every fish glow and shows its shape, so you can identify the species before you cast.
  • Cast close. Aim as near the fish as you can and as far from other species as possible.

Bait and lures, by size

The game lists a "preferred" bait for each species, but players have tested this: in practice, fish respond to a bait's category by their size. Community

  • Small fish take bread, corn, cheese or live bait (worms, crickets, crayfish). They ignore lures.
  • Medium fish take live bait or lures, and bread, corn or cheese if no small fish are near. Use a lure when small fish keep stealing the bait.
  • Large fish take lures, and live bait if no medium fish are near. They ignore bread, corn and cheese.
  • Legendary fish take only special lures, sold at the Lagras bait and tackle shop after you start the "A Fisher of Fish" stranger mission.

The fight

  • Fish nibble before they bite. The bigger the fish, the longer it nibbles. Wait until it pulls, then hook it.
  • Pull the rod the opposite way the fish swims. Reel in only when the fish stops splashing, or the line may snap.
  • Large and legendary fish can pull line out. Lock the reel, but release every couple of seconds so it does not snap.

After the catch

  • Release it. Letting a fish go raises your honor, and releasing a legendary fish lets you catch it again.
  • Keep it. Small and medium fish go in the satchel. Large ones must be carried in your hands or on a horse, one at a time on the horse.
  • Cook it. Cooked fish restores your cores. Small and medium fish must be broken down first. Large fish are cooked at a campfire while you hold them.
  • Donate or sell. Pearson takes fish for provisions, and perfect whole fish raise honor. Butchers pay well for sockeye salmon and steelhead trout.
  • Legendary fish cannot be sold, cooked or donated. They are sent to Jeremy Gill from a post office.
  • Without a rod. Only a small game arrow keeps a shot fish in good condition. Dynamite takes fish in bulk but ruins their quality and lowers honor.

Health and honor

Catching with a rod gives Health XP: 10 for small fish, 20 for medium and large, and 30 for a legendary. Catch and release is a steady way to raise honor.

Fishing is part of Master Hunter rank 8 and Survivalist ranks 1, 5, 9 and 10. Challenges

The fifteen species

Every fish and its legendary version

The same fifteen species appear in Red Dead Online, but legendary versions are a Story Mode feature. Community checked September 30, 2026.

SpeciesCommon sizeFleshLegendary version
BluegillSmallGrittyMedium
Bullhead CatfishSmallGrittyMedium
Chain PickerelSmallFlakyMedium
Channel CatfishLargeGrittyLarge
Lake SturgeonLargeFlakyLarge
Largemouth BassMediumFlakyLarge
Longnose GarLargeGrittyLarge
MuskieLargeFlakyLarge
Northern PikeLargeFlakyLarge
PerchSmallFlakyMedium
Redfin PickerelSmallFlakyMedium
Rock BassSmallFlakyMedium
Smallmouth BassMediumFlakyLarge
Sockeye SalmonMediumSucculentLarge
Steelhead TroutMediumSucculentLarge